Reading Trading Results
Before copying any strategy, you need to understand its track record. Services like MyFXBook provide verified trading statistics, but the numbers mean nothing if you do not know how to interpret them. This lesson teaches you to read the metrics that matter.
What Is MyFXBook?
MyFXBook is a third-party verification platform that connects to a trader's live account and independently tracks performance. The trader cannot edit or fake the results (assuming the account is verified). It shows trades, equity curves, statistics, and risk metrics in a standardised format.
When evaluating a copy-trading strategy, always look for MyFXBook verification (or equivalent platforms like FXBlue or MQL5). Self-reported results without independent verification should be treated with extreme skepticism.
Gain vs ROI
These two numbers often cause confusion:
Gain (Absolute %) — The total percentage change in the account from the starting balance. If the account started at $10,000 and is now at $15,000, the gain is 50%. This includes all deposits and withdrawals and is adjusted accordingly.
ROI (Return on Investment) — On MyFXBook, this may be calculated differently from gain, particularly when deposits and withdrawals have occurred. It attempts to show the return relative to the total capital invested, not just the starting balance.
Always check whether the number being advertised is gain or ROI, and over what time period. "200% gain" over three years is very different from 200% gain in three months (the latter would be extraordinary and likely unsustainable).
Drawdown
MyFXBook shows several drawdown metrics:
- Max drawdown % — The largest peak-to-trough decline. This is the single most important risk number. A strategy showing 60% max drawdown means that at some point, the account lost 60% from its highest equity before recovering.
- Daily/Monthly drawdown — The worst single-day or single-month decline. Useful for understanding how volatile the ride is.
- Relative drawdown — Drawdown as a percentage of equity at the peak. This is more meaningful than absolute drawdown for accounts with deposits/withdrawals.
A common mistake: focusing on the gain number while ignoring drawdown. A strategy with 100% gain and 60% max drawdown is very different from one with 100% gain and 15% max drawdown. The second is far superior on a risk-adjusted basis.
Win Rate
Win rate is the percentage of trades that close in profit. A 70% win rate means 7 out of 10 trades are winners.
Win rate alone tells you almost nothing useful. Here is why:
- A strategy can have 90% win rate but lose money if the average loss is 10x the average win (many small wins, rare large losses).
- A strategy can have 30% win rate and be highly profitable if the average win is 5x the average loss (few big wins, many small losses).
Win rate must always be evaluated alongside the average win/loss ratio.
Profit Factor
Profit factor = Gross profit ÷ Gross loss. It is the single most useful efficiency metric.
- Below 1.0 — The strategy is losing money overall.
- 1.0–1.5 — Marginally profitable. After fees and slippage, may not be viable.
- 1.5–2.0 — Solidly profitable. This is where most good strategies land.
- Above 2.0 — Excellent, but verify the sample size. Very high profit factors on few trades may not be sustainable.
Be wary of profit factors above 3.0 on less than 100 trades — the sample is too small to be statistically meaningful.
Sample Size and Time
This is often overlooked. A strategy with 50 trades over 2 months tells you very little. Market conditions vary enormously across seasons, rate cycles, and geopolitical regimes. A meaningful track record typically needs:
- Minimum 6 months, ideally 12+ months
- At least 100 trades (more for scalping strategies)
- Performance through different market regimes (trending, ranging, volatile, calm)
A strategy that only performed well during a strong gold trend may fail completely when gold enters a range.
The Equity Curve
The equity curve is a chart showing account value over time. Look for:
- Smooth upward slope — Consistent profitability with controlled drawdowns. This is the ideal.
- Staircase pattern — Periods of flat performance followed by sharp jumps. May indicate a strategy that holds losing trades and rarely takes losses — these can blow up spectacularly.
- Jagged peaks and valleys — High volatility in returns. Even if the endpoint is profitable, the ride may be too rough for most followers to endure.
Red Flags in Statistics
- No verification (self-reported results only)
- Very short track record (<3 months) with large gains
- No losing trades — this means the strategy never closes losers and holds through drawdowns
- Average trade duration of days/weeks with no stop losses
- Large discrepancy between gain and balance graph (indicating deposits to cover losses)
Key Takeaways
- Always look for independently verified results (MyFXBook, FXBlue)
- Drawdown matters more than gain — a smooth equity curve beats a volatile one
- Win rate alone is meaningless without average win/loss ratio context
- Profit factor above 1.5 is solid; above 2.0 is excellent (with enough trades)
- Demand 6+ months and 100+ trades minimum before trusting a track record
Ready to try copy-trading?
Learn more →